2013年2月3日

网友在论坛和部落格对于同一样产品的评价两面倒。I Observed a Negative Relationship between Comments about a Same Product on Forum and Blog


那天,小流氓上网寻找有关“A Huat 白咖啡”。谷歌搜寻结果显示,有关该产品的资料来源主要来自:A Huat 白咖啡的官方网站(既是Powerroot),论坛和部落格。游览一篇过后,小流氓发现一个现象:网友在论坛和部落格对于同一样产品的评价两面倒。

来看一看部分摘自Lowyat论坛对于“A Huat 白咖啡”的评论:

penisama: tipu manusia punya
edwardstevens: not good at all
BallCracker: i bought it last month...drink one cup....nothing so special about it....i might as well get back to old town white coffee...
Hollow21: Old Town > Ah Huat
narf03: if you dance like that while you drink, then very gooding, else, its just shiting.
fuzzy: Chek Hup > Hwei Hwang > Kopi Bru > Old Town > Ah Huat > Neskapi
rockpoper: Rubbish > Starbucks Coffee > Ah Huat
mazwan182: Aik Cheong>all coffee

来看一看部分摘自部落格留言对于“A Huat 白咖啡”的评论:

Simple Person: I tried it and it is good..
It is manufacture by Power Root.. I think they make a good decision for coming out a chinese name..
I got few packets and I bought for my friend in China .. and they love it..
mNhL: I tried it at Aeon too......very nice and smooth. But I did not buy coz I still have 2 packets (diff brands) of 3 in 1 not yet finished.
I like the jingles. Ah Niu sang very good.
Yan: Interesting. I must buy this coffee one day and try it myself. I am also a coffee lover.
Kitty: Will look out for this brand when I go shopping. I love coffee.
Agnes: First time I see this brand of coffee. I am a coffee lover too..have not seen it in the hypermarket here yet. If i see I sure buy to have a taste of it..
Andrew Wan:I always hear its advertisement from the radio. Really good? I only drink old town...gonna try this up and see.
Wabbitfoot: ya, i saw the advertisment as well. I was laughing non stop the first time i saw it. it's too funny ler...but i havent try it thou...
Sam yuk yuk now, wanna go buy one packet from gaint already. hehe
Libby: Gonna see if I can get this in JB when I go there this Friday! Huat ah! I take 3 in 1 coffee too.

论坛对于产品的评价较为“直接”,其中有直接且偏激的言论。然而,排除这些直接且偏激的言论,论坛不乏中肯的留言。论坛的结论是:没有正面的评价。

部落格留言对于产品的评价则是相反,其中更有和作者看法相符的留言。其大多数更显示对该产品有兴趣以及愿意尝试。部落格的结论是:没有负面的评价。

至于读者应该选者哪一个成为可信的资源,就留给读者自己决定了。

~而小流氓却亲口试喝了各种口味的A Huat白咖啡,下回分享。I tried "A Huat White Coffee" before. How is it taste? Will share it on my next post.~
I tried to search for more about "A Huat White Coffee" that day. As per Google top-est search result, there are three main sources of it, which is official website of the product, forum and blogs. After a few viewing of the resources, I observed a negative relationship between comments about the same product on forum and blog.

Let's have a look on some of the comments retrieved from Lowyat Forum:

penisama: tipu manusia punya
edwardstevens: not good at all
BallCracker: i bought it last month...drink one cup....nothing so special about it....i might as well get back to old town white coffee...
Hollow21: Old Town > Ah Huat
narf03: if you dance like that while you drink, then very gooding, else, its just shiting.
fuzzy: Chek Hup > Hwei Hwang > Kopi Bru > Old Town > Ah Huat > Neskapi
rockpoper: Rubbish > Starbucks Coffee > Ah Huat
mazwan182: Aik Cheong>all coffee

This is some of the comments retrieved from a Blog:

Simple Person: I tried it and it is good..
It is manufacture by Power Root.. I think they make a good decision for coming out a chinese name..
I got few packets and I bought for my friend in China .. and they love it..
mNhL: I tried it at Aeon too......very nice and smooth. But I did not buy coz I still have 2 packets (diff brands) of 3 in 1 not yet finished.
I like the jingles. Ah Niu sang very good.
Yan: Interesting. I must buy this coffee one day and try it myself. I am also a coffee lover.
Kitty: Will look out for this brand when I go shopping. I love coffee.
Agnes: First time I see this brand of coffee. I am a coffee lover too..have not seen it in the hypermarket here yet. If i see I sure buy to have a taste of it..
Andrew Wan:I always hear its advertisement from the radio. Really good? I only drink old town...gonna try this up and see.
Wabbitfoot: ya, i saw the advertisment as well. I was laughing non stop the first time i saw it. it's too funny ler...but i havent try it thou...
Sam yuk yuk now, wanna go buy one packet from gaint already. hehe
Libby: Gonna see if I can get this in JB when I go there this Friday! Huat ah! I take 3 in 1 coffee too.

As you can see, Forum users tend to comment in a "direct" way. It's including some extremism comments. Nevertheless, Forum comments is pertinent by excluding those go to extreme. But it's ending with no positive comment.

Blog comments go to opposite. Some showing the same opinions as writer, most were showing their interest in the product and willing to give it a try. The conclusion is there is no negative comments about the product.

As for which to be trustworthy resource as an internet user? It's your decision.

6 条评论:

  1. 这样子要相信谁的看法 ?
    我本身比较不喜欢论坛
    有时都不知道他们什么时候讲的话可以相信
    因为有些讲到太夸
    有些讲到太偏激(很不客气)
    而且要follow 他们的对话找答案,有点费神

    回复删除
    回复
    1. Sock Peng,
      对的论坛网友真的是很不客气,有的还很狠毒,所以很多艺人都不看“网友”的评论。因为“网友”的身份无从查明。
      部落客的话,当累积一定的公信力,大家自然而然就会follow了。

      删除
  2. 虽然说论坛的人比较直接,可是在blogger界也有厂商请的'枪手',所以还是要自己试了才知道 xD

    回复删除
    回复
    1. 对呀,所以不能人云亦云。不过论坛也有“假扮的网友”。真真假假,共参考就好了。

      删除
  3. 此评论已被博客管理员删除。

    回复删除
  4. 此评论已被博客管理员删除。

    回复删除

交流一下。

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...